Видео

How your light.

I cannot explain tool. They exist regardless of explanations, I cannot.

I cannot explain tool. They exist regardless of explanations.

She is registering zero brain cells. Derp. 🤦‍♂️

Church abandoned her - God didn´t. Jesus fought the same "forces" and he was the son of God. We got to realize that this life we live here as a person ("persona") is a blink of an eye, a temptation in itself. Judith remained faithful - mimicing Jesus. If you´re an atheist, then she died in peace towards being happy in staying true to her faith. If you´re a christian, then you´ll be happy for her even more so. Since now she is standing UP with the true king and it was all fucking worth it. Maynard is an intelligent artist, but can´t (understandably) see further than his understanding of faith. I love this song and Judith made it possible. The anguish you see here is for a purpose and that was her´s...you just have to see further than that. Thank you guys for the reaction and thank you Maynard and Judith for making this lesson possible for all of us. Godspeed !

Good cdid. 💚

I don't care what anyone says....if a being all powerful that could save someone with just an inkling of power and withholds doing so is WAY more evil than any demon or devil dumb Christians could make up! It is a moral problem for religious idiots because it is a self imposed rule god put on himself. Even after 2000 years no one can worm around it or excuse it LMFAO....so stupid!

If ur gonna continue put up a video thing otherwise its just watching u look down

This song isnt just about news media, although that is one prime example of a larger group of or need for tradegy in general. Every human is included in what he talks about even if one thinks they are not. I'll give some evidence... Has a book, movie, play, etc., ever been written where no conflict occurs? ever? What if there was a book that simply was all mundane daily stuff of a person and absolutely nothing interesting happened? Readers would be confused, bored, and not even understand why something was written without a fundamental plot. Even if it's not "death" he is, in the larger picture talking about "tradegy". Even in a TV sitcom something will cause suffering due to a comical misunderstanding or odd funny occurence that disrupts their life in a negative way (even if its minor and temporary). We are drawn to conflict, (i.e. plot). Weather is mass death on the news or we enjoy reading Harry Potter, we need to view conflict, its a fundamental part of humans.

What a lucky girl!

You must hear jerk off by tool ❤

They lay down the music track first then Maynard writes the lyrics! fuckin genious!

basically his mum a devote believer never questioned why she was given such suffering so he asks those questions for her and any god having given us a questioning mind would want us to ask why.

5:03 Your superman analogy has no basis in fact, even if it is a fictional character. FFS, think harder. What you suggest that he can't allow or prevent is just reaching.

4:36 Nice deflection. Not actually acknowledging valid arguments. Trying to reinterpret a reaction rather than accept the simplest solution. "YEAH. JUST AH... COMMON ARGUMENT... IT'S A SHORTCOMING."... No, the argument is valid, and you're just trying to gloss over that by suggesting a wrong interpretation. Keep on deflecting and not really answering the question. That's all you in that camp are good for.

They played this song on the radio everyday.🤣

brainless christians ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

I've been in a binge watching reactions and dissertations about this song and this far not one got it right, not even Cristian pastors, Occam's razor would point that I am the one who didn't get it, but I believe it's not the case, maybe I'll make a vid about it

Wow guys don’t even understand the God you claim to love and serve. There is no love grief or compassion in the way you speak of this mans pain. THIS BEYOND ALL ELSE, is the reason so many people turn away from God. Sad.

My favorite all-encompassing ending to a song is Octivarium by Dream Theater

Just a couple of cult followers following the "flock" fuck your god tho

This is up there with anything Tool have done tbf

Never interrupt a Pink Floyd song, leave the comments to the end 😊

Many of us ex christians would rather burn than bow to tyranny

Wow I didn't know there was a version (exact same audio) with only a still photo, lol. You woulda enjoyed it so much more, with the video of them playing it at a lot younger age, in their 20s.

Too much stopping and taking

I grew up Christian, (by my parents) I'm non-denominational now as an adult. I find it weird that nobody picks up on the "spite spear into his side" line where Jesus was actually killed by a roman soldier with a spear after being taken down by the cross. Religious adults blow my mind when it comes down to how little they know about their own faith, and are basically brainwashed. That's why I'm not religious. 99% of religious people believe what they believe, because they popped out of a vagina, in a certain part of the world, at a certain point in time...and their parents and local culture taught them "this is what reality is"

Brutally magnificent lyrics. Tells the tale of the cycle of abuse. It’s terrifying and brilliant at the same time.

Nice..you two look alike...dived right in two

I don't get how people can be so collected hearing this for the first time. The vocals are so good it makes me want to scream lmao.

@$#? YOUR GOD!

I wanna see their reactions after reading some parts of Leviticus and Duederotomy. Talk about insane and horrible.

we are never good enough

god sets us up to fail

"Ghost OF mother's bed?" Who the fuck wrote those lyrics?? 🤣 You should always look up the lyrics from a good source. That shit has to be auto-generated or something.

A consumer of rampant consumerism calls someone out for providing what is being consumed. I get it.

Christianity is bizarre.

I know im late to the party, but i had to comment after your mention of the story of Job. I find that story horrible. The devil nad god are having a disagreement about his loyal followers as if they hang out togeather. I thought they were enemies. Also, does the devil question god? As if there is a possibility that god does not know or is in error. God then tortures a man that loves him just to win a bet with the devil? I find that story morally abhorrent. On the surface it seems fine but its horrible and questions gods very nature and begs the question of the nature of gods and the devils relationship. Every part is a moral failure period. Please explain how im wrong, i dare you.

I don't believe God will be offended is someone give them the F bomb. If it was he would strike them where they stood. or give them the can swear without mouth threatment like in the Matrix. because if God get offended this this will mean A) God Exist B) He/She/It is pissed out about you ! We all know that God works in mysterious way and trying to imply our logic to him/her/it actions is pure waste of time.

It's even worse because the people of her church told her it happened because she wasn't a good enough Christian

Interesting that you thought of Across the Universe, because the last verse uses a phrase from that song, "Inviting and inciting me". And Roger Waters considered suing Andrew Lloyd Webber for stealing thar riff for Phantom of the Opera. He never did but used to refer to him as Andrew Floyd Webber

Adrian Smith and Dave Murray on lead guitars here.

The story of Jobe just shows that we are tools for God and His ends and will allow and even cause His faithful to suffer.

THE GOAT HM BAND.

yeah dudes

Judith spend her life paralyzed loving God, and avoiding her son. Judith should have spent her dying days touring with her son. One life, and she chose God over her son, and that bothered Maynard.

Listen to Comfortably Numb - Pulse edition. Many of us consider the second guitar solo as the best ever

The story of Job is a horror story! It highlights God's cruelty for no other reason than playing a game with Satan. Why Christians view this story in such a positive light has never made sense to me, even when I was a devoted Christian myself.

To say Bruce Dickinson is like all 80’s singers is to compare Michael Jordan to a guy at a pickup game at LA Fitness. Lol

Most people, including clergy and Christian leaders just don't understand what's in the Bible which is what breeds this anger. All they have to do is look at the story of Job for an example. The devil claims Job is only faithful because he gets a lot of blessings and favor from God. So he tells God that if takes those things away Job will curse God to his face. And God says fine. Wanna test that out YOU take his blessings away and make him suffer. Because he's been faithful and I'm not touching him. This shows a couple of things. One, when stuff happens to good people it is not God that's responsible for it. He is not stealing our loved ones back to Heaven when they die or killing them in wars and such. Bad stuff happens to good people because the devil is an asshole. Not God. If you're gonna believe in one, you gotta believe in the other. Two, after Job went through all he went through, because he did keep his faith, he was rewarded double. Which is what Judith was likely counting on and why she could keep her faith. God doesn't do any bad things to anybody and he has no need to prematurely kill good people. And he rewards if you persevere. This is not what a lot of so called religions teach, but it's right there in the Bible they claim to follow. This is just one example.